Tuesday, May 30, 2006

Caste away

Since we all like talking about being deep in shit, let’s take a look at the issue from arse-upwards. Let us look at it from the end point.
When our beloved government came to power along with their Communist comrades, there was a talk about introducing reservations in the private sector! How brilliant is that!
Like most of the problems dogging us, the reservation issue too is a result of someone else’s petty politics. Arjun Singh, VP Singh one and the same thing. I was skimming through another incredibly boring edition of The Week magazine and I found a useful bit of news. Apparently, the last caste based census was conducted in 1931. Since us Indians have demonstrated that it is possible to multiply like the rabbits and beat the rabbits at their own game, the data from the 1931 census is as useful as the dinosaur census.
Today, who are these backward castes? How do you identify them? The present time is handing out jobs for all regardless of social classifications. The system today is arguably quite impartial. When was the last time you had to name your caste on the CV?
There is an urgent need for the policy makers to forge their balls in steel and re-define and restate that instead of backward castes, we are better off with a Backward class reservation. Many families from the upper castes live in abject poverty. Conversely, numerous families from the lower castes have done well economically.

This is an excerpt from the Indian Constitution:

Legal identification of Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes
Selection criteria for scheduled castes
1. Cannot be served by clean Brahmans
2. Cannot be served by the barbers, water-carriers, tailors, etc. who serve the caste Hindus
3. Pollutes a high-caste Hindu by contact or by proximity
4. Is one from whose hands a caste Hindu cannot take water
5. Is debarred from using public amenities such as roads, ferries, wells, or schools
6. Will not be treated as an equal by high-caste men of the same educational qualification in ordinary social intercourse
7. Is depressed on account of the occupation followed and, but for that, occupation would be subject to no social disability
Selection criteria for scheduled tribes
1. Tribal origin
2. Primitive ways of life and habitation in remote and less accessible areas
3. General backwardness in all respects
Source: Constitution of India



Now that you have read the above, the whole issue of SC/ST OBC reservations looks like fresh horse manure. We have not changed our definitions with changing times and rocketing economy. Lets have a small section of our resources reserved for people who are lagging behind. But NOT without changing the criteria for the eligibility.

Alright alright, I’m talking through my bum. If we had a temper for change even Mandal would not have happened.

Since the last few generations, we highly privileged upper caste back benchers, have quietly accepted reservation policies and vote bank politics. By now most of us have realized that in this country where votes are catalyzed with arrack sachets, it is unfair to expect political leaders to stand up for us. Weeks have passed and no leader has spoken yet. Surprisingly, the supposed couch potato generation has found its guts. For me it was simply unbelievable to see our friends unite in different parts of the nation, making silent protests. The very manner in which the protests were done makes me proud to say that I belong to this generation. Gandhi is passé.
I cannot really speculate about the outcome of this mass movement. Maybe we will be victorious and can force a fair policy. Maybe we will all be brushed aside in the interest of national disintegration. Whatever it is, surely we must not stop now. I am not expecting a miracle to happen. Some where in the corner of my mind, I realize that a real solution to this problem can be arrived at only if the real OBC voice their opinion through real people (not some farce political party or leader). I am sure that most OBC today, are tired of being insulted with free quotas. Of course, everyone’s conscience knows that real equality is when you are neither privileged nor deprived. An OBC doesn’t really want his intelligence and ego hurt by being labelled the caste which needs a push to clear exams, get through professional courses AND a push to get a job.
This mass movement should have been by OBC and not the so called upper caste. It is the OBC who should have protested the perpetual insult programme. They should come forward and ask their guardian angels like Arjun Singh to piss off. It is only they who can put an end to this.

My two cents.....

4 comments:

Anonymous said...

Foreword: When the Mandal Commission’s recommendations were enforced, I was just a naïve schoolgirl, way too happy at the unscheduled “holidays” to notice the grim reality. The mass self-immolation, the smuggled copies of “Newsweek”, the excited discussions of parents, everything told me that all was not right with the world. Now, as I look back, the piece of news that had created the stir was that certain opportunities were deemed beyond the scope of certain individuals simply because of their family name. With the recent decisions of the Ministry of HRD, time has come a full circle, and this time there is no school break to cloud out my sight.


India has always been a demographers nightmare: a veritable medley of humankind, practising unfathomable customs, following innumerable creeds and belonging to different castes. One common factor that unites us all is the stupidity that is associated with the masses. Perhaps, the one characteristic that sets Indians apart from the rest of the world is how individual brilliance translates into collective imbecility. The average Indian is genetically disposed towards an above average intelligence and the Indian populace has a predisposition towards being annoyingly foolish. Amidst all this, there is widespread economic inequity. And there in lies our biggest vulnerability.

One of the parameters of measuring the development a nation is making is the diversity in the economic status of the citizens. The narrower the gap, the closer the nation is to “social justice”.

Lets take the facts first. The union government is planning to increase the percentage of reserved seats in all central universities to 49.5%. The increase will be of 27 percentage points over the existing 22.5%, the beneficiaries in this case being the OBCs who make up 52% of the population in India.

Now lets examine these facts under the light of logic. By definition, the most backward classes are “scheduled” and no other section should be given more reservation than them. In such a case, if the quantum of proposed reservation is “explained” by the population of a certain section, it can only point to politics of votes. What these regulations mean is that now of all the seats available to the section of the population handicapped by not having (perceived) social handicaps, a touch over one third will disappear. They will go to the single largest section of the voting public: enough to grant an absolute majority to any political party that can gain their sympathies. Obviously, no party would want to let a chance like this go. Consequently, from now on, there will be students in what are arguably the world’s best academic institutions who have neither the mettle that is required to be there nor the talent required to complete the courses they have been pushed into. Obviously these candidates with their half-baked intellects will not be able to keep pace with the curriculum, which strains the brightest talent in the country. This will lead to frustration among them and may even cause them to drop out. In that case, through the new policies, we have succeeded in: a) keeping out genuine talent from the institutes, b) forced some others to do something their intellects are not prepared for, causing them needless distress and wasting a significant portion of their lifetime. One needs to understand here that these don’t only apply to candidates from the reserved categories. Any candidate who gets admitted to an academy that demands extremely high levels of proficiency without possessing it in the right amounts can only look forward to a bitter experience. That is the exact reason that these institutions have an entrance examination in the first place. Diluting this quality will eventually cause the standards of these institutes to dip, and we will have yet another set of mediocre institutions.

No clear thinking person can disagree with the fact that the downtrodden need to be accorded special privileges to bring them up to a reasonable standard of living. But the way in which these privileges are decided certainly merits closer inspection. Reserving seats for higher education for a particular community, ostensibly to uplift it, while primary education remains neglected is obviously not the right approach. If the government had been interested in anything but the votes, they would have made better primary and secondary schooling arrangements, so that at the end of their schooling students from these communities could qualify for these institutions in the regular way. Agreed, this approach is more difficult and requires more changes, but substituting an easy option for the right one does not make too much sense. An analogy comes to mind. Say, a certain portion of the engine of a rocket needs to be made of titanium, since it can withstand much higher temperatures. Now the same property renders its forging quite difficult. In this case if some wise guy comes up with the idea of using wood since its more workable, his intelligence cannot be appreciated enough.

One place where these knee-jerk reservations do make sense is the Parliament. If a large section of the country remains underdeveloped despite putting in special plans for them, it is time to seek that section’s participation in the policies governing them. Hence the only place where these reservations make sense is in the ministries. Besides, that is the only job that can be done with abysmal levels of education.

Anonymous said...

If you agree with this, please sign this petition online:

http://www.petitiononline.com/No_Quota/petition.html

mpulztracker said...

I dont see how reserving seats in the parliament is going to help bring equality. U can expect those ministers to play on caste votebank lines. So we are back to square one.
The other point I tried to make is, how do u know that OBC are 52% of the population ? The truth there actually is no real count. The last census (2001) counted SC/ST numbers and many OBC were forced into that classification. Its a veritable mess.

Anonymous said...

this was forwarded on the internet...enjoy!!!!!!!

Sun is rising as usual in the east. I am standing here outside the school, waiting for my 10 yr kid. He studies in class 2. Only this year he could get admission into the school. For the last 5yrs, admissions were closed for the general category students. School bell rings. I can see a lot of happy children coming out of the gate, i waited for half an hour and my kid came at last after other children as general students are not allowed to cross the gate unless other OBC/SC/ST students have crossed the gates.



OBC/SC/ST fathers drive away their children in classy cars. But I have to walk back home with my kid a 5km stretch.

I lost my car some years back when Govt. came with a rule that general people have to deposit a tax equal to cost of their cars failing to which i had to sell the car. As far as buses are concerned, the seats in buses are reserved for OBC/SC/ST. So no place there also.



After walking some 5km in scorching heat i finally reached home. It was wednesday... shit, no electricity. Every mon,wed,thu,sat is power cut in the houses of General category population .So that SC/ST/OBC can be uplifted by providing them with every opportunity and in that consideration electricity is an important factor. It is 10:00 pm in night no electricity at home. Its very hot inside the four walls of home .So i dare to step out in park with my wife and kid. I seated myself with my family on a secluded bench in garden. It was hardly 5 min ... a guard came to us strolling in the park. He asked me what caste you belong to.I said with some hesitation … G…General.

He asked me to pay a fine of Rs.200 and get out of the park.



My Fault...

The bench i was sitting on was meant for again the SC/ST/OBC. For their upliftment, peace of mind is an essential things. So govt came with this decision to reserve benches for them. Kudos to them...



It is early in the morning ...the newspaper wala just knocked the door. I took the newspaper and started reading ..,its independence day . i never used to forget this days some 20 yrs back. My kid hardly knows wat 15th august is,because never told him any stories of greatness of our country or anything realted to country.I don't feel like telling him the failures after freedom.



On front page of newspaper, in a corner their is a news about a OBC member getting 6 months imprisonment in "BAL SUDHAR GRAHA" from a juvenile court for murdering and raping a six year old girl. Yes the rules have been amended, since the last 5 years. The Culprit was a 25 year old OBC so age relaxation was provided for trial of crime. So he was taken to juvenile court, since there is an age relaxation for OBC/SC/ST.



About 11 am some one gave me the BAD news about demise of one of my neighbors and friend Mr.Mehta. I went to his house for condolence next day, his body was lying there still rotting in the heat. I asked his son about the Cremation .His son told me "Many reserved category have died yesterday so we are not getting entry to cremation ground ". This rule is the latest from Govt. where the seats in cremation ground will be reserved for SC/ST/OBC for their upliftment. Finally next day Mehta ji was cremated. i could see the sun setting through the Flames burning a liberated Body, liberated from caste n creed. I was surprised sun still sets in the west?



It was about 9 pm, i was about to sleep in my bed my son came to me with innocence in his eyes , inquisitively he asked me the question: "what is reservation?" He asked me where u listened that. He suddenly burst in tears... i asked him to keep...quiet



But i could listen through his sobs "mujhe bhi reservation chahiye". How can i convince him its no other toy in the market i can get for him? He kept crying that night, claiming many of "his classmates have got reservation". To make him quiet i said ok, i'll buy you reservation at your next B'day. HOPE he understands the bloody concept soon.



In order to overcome this scenario, I have thought of various answers:

Marry an OBC. (Forget your love that you loved for yrs)
Settle outside India. (Become an NRI)
Beg the Indian army to take control of the situation. Make this country as a Dictatorship & shoot all this bloody thieves, murderers who have become politicians.


I think answer number 3 is the best option>>>>>>>